Hi, friends!
Welcome to the third part of my series of posts about why multi-level marketing companies are flimmy and flammy. Yep, I'm still not done talking about why I hate pyramid schemes. This time, I thought I'd share some product comparisons between things sold by MLMs and legitimate businesses.
If the products being sold by MLMs were decent or at least decently priced, it would be easier to ignore the awful setup of these companies. However, MLM products are usually expensive, awful, or both. (After all, the people at the top of the pyramid make money off of the sales of the people they've signed up. That money has to come from somewhere!) There are exceptions, but even a nice product being sold at an okay price can't make up for the fact that pyramid schemes are designed to suck money from the people who join them.
Since makeup is something several popular MLMs sell and also something I enjoy talking about, I'll start with some cosmetic MLMs. I won't be mentioning every MLM out there because there are just
too many, but I'll try to get all of the major ones.
Avon's prices are about in the same realm as brands like Revlon and L'oreal. I've only used three things from them - a lip balm, a nail polish, and some lotion - and they've all been fine. Nothing to write home about, but they do their jobs. Avon has been around for forever, the salespeople aren't usually too awful or pushy, and the prices and products are both fine. It seems to be the least terrible MLM overall, which is sort of like saying something is the least disgusting kind of vomit. Still not something pleasant that you want in your life, but it could be worse.
Mary Kay's stuff is a bit pricier, more along the lines of Clinique or other brands sold at Sephora. I'm pretty sure I've never tried anything from them, nor have I ever heard anyone outside the company praise their products. Nobody seems to enjoy the "pampering sessions" they get roped into, so I would guess their products aren't exactly spectacular.
SeneGence,
the company that has LipSense, is really pushing it with their prices. Their mascara is $28, which is the same price as a mascara from Kevyn Aucoin or Estee Lauder. The only product from them that I've really heard anything about is their infamous LipSense. It does stay on your lips pretty well, but it also apparently burns like crazy, smells like alcohol, and is incredibly uncomfortable to wear. (Sellers like to tell you that LipSense is
supposed to feel like you're holding a lighter to your lips and that the pain just means it's purging your lips of inferior products or some nonsense to that effect.) If I'm paying $25 for a tube of liquid lipstick, I'd expect it to be better than that.
Younique charges luxury prices for products that definitely don't seem to have luxury results. I actually went pretty in-depth with this and compared the prices for most of their products to things sold at Sephora, and hoo boy am I shocked at the gall this company has. Personally, I think it's dumb for any brand to charge $26 for a single cream eye shadow, but the fact that Younique's cream shadows are $26 is particularly infuriating when you realize that brands like Natasha Denona and Givenchy are about the same price. In fact, you get a
better deal from Natasha Denona (which is a phrase that has probably never been used before now) because her cream shadows are only $2 more but contain 6 grams instead of 4.5 grams. What in the actual heck? I was also particularly appalled at their 30 mL bottle of "beauty oil" that they charge $75 for even though it's basically just squalane oil. Oh, and I can't forget their rose water toner that's so overpriced that you'd be better off getting a 200 mL bottle from Lancome for $27 instead of their 100 mL bottle for $39. When
Lancome is the option that makes more economic sense, something is very, very wrong.
I could keep going like this for a while. Just know that Younique's prices are completely redonkulous and their products aren't even nice or in pretty packaging. (This
official video from corporate seems like a parody, but it's not. The palette really is that bad.)
Moving on from makeup,
Rodan + Fields sells skincare that definitely costs way more than it needs to. Their lash serum is $150 and also the subject of a
lawsuit. I highly doubt their $64 eye cream (15 mL) provides results that are actually worth $64.
I don't think I've ever seen anyone I know talk about
Monat, but I want to bring it up anyway because I need to warn you all to stay far, far away from these hair products. Not only are the bottles of shampoo $30+, but Monat has
several lawsuits against it. People who have used Monat have had their hair fall out and not grow back.
 |
Super expensive shampoo and conditioner that make you bald? I'm going to have to pass. |
Scrolling through the
Color Street website and looking at the terribly Photoshopped pictures of their nail polish strips made me giggle. What they sell is kind of like stickers made of nail polish. Each pack is around $10-$13, which makes it cheaper than going to a salon but still (probably) more expensive than buying a new bottle of nail polish and painting your nails at home. The advantages are that you can put patterns or art on your nails without needing the skill to do it manually and you don't have to wait for layers of polish to dry. The disadvantages are the price (compared to buying the polish and maybe a small paintbrush or a dotting tool) and the fact that you're buying something from a pyramid scheme. The good news is that if you want the same product (from the same parent company) at a better price and without the dodgy MLM aspect,
Incoco is your friend. Sally Hansen also sells the same kind of product for a better price than Color Street.
ColourPop recently came out with some nail decals, too, and I definitely trust their quality a lot more than Color Street.
Sc
Amway has a whole bunch of product categories, ranging from $45 bags of "slim popcorn" (which give you one fifth the amount of popcorn as a bag of Kirkland movie theater butter microwave popcorn, yet nearly half the amount of calories as an entire bag of Costco's buttery goodness) to $22 eyeliner pencils to laundry detergent that costs three times as much per liter as normal brands. The co-founder, Richard DeVos, was the father-in-law of Betsy DeVos and was also filthy rich thanks to all the people his company duped.
Nu Skin's products include a $20 toothpaste, a $29 mascara, and a night cream that gives you less bang for your buck than the Laneige water sleeping mask. If you're feeling extra splurgey, you can buy a $348 kit that has what seems to be a Clarisonic-type brush and a couple of products to use with it. Who is buying this stuff, Gwyneth Paltrow?!
 |
Suddenly, the $169 Clarisonic brush doesn't seem as ludicrous. It still is, but it's not as bad as the Nu Skin version. |
One of the MLMs infamous for having its reps send rude messages to people is
Beachbody, which deals with fitness and exercise. Beachbody "coaches" don't always realize that what they see as reaching out to offer their products to someone is essentially telling that person that they need to lose weight. They sell pricey workout DVDs and various equipment, like a $30 yoga mat.
ItWorks! (does it, though?) focuses on products that are supposedly for your health and wellness. They sell supplements, "fat fighter" pills, essential oils, and a single-use facial sheet mask that somehow costs $59. Legally, they have to say that the FDA has not approved their claims about their products and that the junk they sell isn't intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Their sellers sure like to imply otherwise. Please have a conversation with an actual doctor if you think you might need some kind of supplement.
 |
What you don't see in this scene is a guy from Buzz Lightyear's high school trying to give him medical advice. |
In the same general vein,
Plexus has more expensive nonsense posing as ~wellness~ and weight management products. For $89.95, you can buy 30 packets of Plexus Slim Hunger Control, a 20-calorie drink that's supposed to help reduce your desire to overeat if you drink it before a meal. Do you know what could do essentially the same thing but with no calories at all? Water! They say to use a packet of that stuff one to two times per day, which means you're paying $90 for something that will last you somewhere between two weeks and a month. A healthy rate of weight loss is a pound or two each week. If you're hoping to use this stuff during your weight loss journey, you'd better be prepared to waste a ton of money.
Who wants to hear about even more snake oils? Hopefully you do.
Young Living is one of the two main essential oil MLMs. (They also apparently have eye shadow quads that are $55 and have lavender essential oil in them. Who the heck do they think they are asking $55 for four shadows?! Charlotte Tilbury quads are $53!) Sellers of YL get a better price than people who aren't part of the company, but you'll still find much better prices looking elsewhere.
For some reason, YL sells oils meant specifically for children, even though some oils are
super dangerous to kids. Peppermint oil is known to cause breathing problems for small children, yet it's found in their "SniffleEase" and "TummyGize" oil blends for kids. The sniffle blend also contains eucalyptus oils, which can cause certain medications to be less effective and cause asthma attacks.
YL also sells animal-specific products even though experts generally
don't recommend using any kind of essential oil on or near your pets because so many of them can cause health problems. Their Animal Scents Ointment, which is meant to be used directly on animals, has tea tree oil, which is known to be harmful to both cats and dogs. The Infect Away blend contains oregano, Mendwell has lavender, ParaGize has peppermint and anise, PuriClean has lavender, and T-Away also has lavender. Either someone at Young Living wants to make people's pets sick or they really don't know how dangerous these oils can be to the innocent animals owned by oil enthusiasts.
And now, a look into Young Living's rival brand,
doTERRA. In my mind, doTERRA is both better and worse than YL. It's worse because the name is obnoxious, but better because its founder wasn't
Gary Young, the baby murderer and phony doctor. Anyway, their oils are even more overpriced than Young Living's. They don't seem to sell oils specifically meant to be used on your kids or pets, though, so that's good.
Thoughts about essential oils that aren't brand-specific:
- Even if the oil you want to use isn't poisonous to your pet, it's probably even more smelly to them than it is to us, and I know I pray that I never get stuck next to an essential oil user on a plane. Diffusing an oil into the air means that tiny bits of oil could land on your pet's fur, which could lead to your pet licking that oil off and ingesting it, which is definitely not something you want. (Don't ingest essential oils, no matter your species!!)
- Essential oil sellers like to say that because their oils are natural, that means they're safe to use. If natural means safe, then I guess things like grizzly bears, arsenic, and poison ivy are totally fine. (Don't worry, campers, that angry grizzly bear is natural so it definitely can't kill you.) Some people are so afraid of "chemicals" that they forget that
everything is a chemical. Sellers will sometimes say that their brand of oil is purer than other brands, which actually just means it's even more dangerous if used incorrectly or undiluted. Strike two, #oilymama.
- Basically, don't use oils for your health issues or else you might give yourself
even more problems to deal with. Personally, I'd rather be sniffly than having a seizure or developing respiratory issues.
I should stop ranting about essential oils now. Back to MLMs!
Scentsy is escentially (heh) Bath and Body Works, but with even more introvert-intimidating employees. Their wax warmers start at $30 and most other products seem to be around the same price as what Bath and Body Works has... if you're shopping there while there are no sales whatsoever. Good luck trying to find a day to do that!
If you've ever wanted a flimsy potato sack of a dress that has an eye-numbing pattern,
LuLaRoe is the company for you! It's harder to directly see the prices of LLR products because of the convoluted system you have to use to buy from their reps, but the general range is about $25 for leggings and $40-$60 for their dresses. Of course, you can also find heaps of LLR clothes in thrift shops because of all the reps who have gone out of business and been left with tons of hideous, unsold inventory. I'd rather brave a crowded mall (y'know, if I had one to go to) and shop for dresses at JC Penney for similar prices but way higher quality. LLR clothing tears easily, sometimes smells musty, and occasionally has
stolen artwork as its pattern.
Cutco is one that pretty much everyone has heard of. Their knives are quite nice, but
very pricey. Their cheapest kitchen knife is $43. The can opener on their website is $61. If I ever decide I want a $51 ice cream scoop or a $76 cheese knife, I know where to look.
 |
Thankfully, Phoebe didn't stick with Cutco for long |
Pampered Chef is another famous MLM with nice kitchen tools at high prices. I remember my mom buying some Pampered Chef stuff from a thrift store when I was a kid. She told me she was excited to find those things because they were good quality. I asked why she didn't get more of their things from a regular store and she told me they were expensive and also weren't sold in stores, which was very confusing to tiny me. I now understand that yes, $13 is definitely too much money for a rubber spatula and my 9" x 13" pan is perfectly functional despite not costing $45. Their small offset spatula is $10 and the same thing from Wilton is about $5.
Want to rid your house of all chemicals? Well, that's not actually possible, but
Norwex lets you pretend you can! They sell "chemical-free" dryer balls (three balls of wool for $30), a $16 toothpaste for kids, and a $30 bottle of oven cleaner. I really hope the whole "cHeMiCaLs ArE eViL" pseudoscience fad dies quickly. (This is where I could make a really dark joke about kids that don't get vaccinated, but I probably shouldn't do that.)
We're finally approaching the end of this long parade of expensiveness. Were you waiting for me to bring up
Tupperware? It's such a widely known brand that the name has become synonymous with any kind of food container. The products are fine - even if they won't withstand
being run over by an orange van - but definitely cost more than they need to. A $35 can opener seems excessive, doesn't it?
That was more writing than I thought it would be. I kept thinking of more and more companies to add to the list! Since MLM reps are usually somewhat secretive about their prices and I never exactly asked for more information, it was a bit of a shock to see just how overpriced some of that stuff is. It's also amusing to see how many of the product pages have a tiny disclaimer about how they don't claim to diagnose, treat, or prevent diseases so that the company can't get in legal trouble when its reps start boasting about how they quit taking their medication and just put essential oils in their drink instead.
If I missed a company you've had a run-in with, let me know and I'll gladly shine the spotlight on their ridiculousness, too.
Tune in next time for the final part of my Pyramid Schemes Are The Worst saga!
Love,
Lizzie